Akron, Ohio's Source for Sports & Collectibles

About Us

About Premier Sports Consignment
Our Story

Premier Sports Consignment was founded by lifelong collectors with a passion for sports memorabilia and helping collectors maximize the value of their collections.

With over 40 years of collecting experience, we combine sports knowledge, market expertise, and personalized service to help collectors and families achieve the best possible return on their collections.

Why Choose Us?

Lifelong collectors with decades of experience
Extensive sports knowledge
Passion for sports memorabilia
Professional handling of collections
Honest evaluations
Personalized service
Estate and downsizing assistance
Trusted by collectors throughout Northeast Ohio

We Are Known For Our:

Knowledge & Professionalism
Expert Customer Service
Consistently Proven Results

Additional Information

Always Accepting Quality Consignments
Free Appraisals

Meet Our Team

Rich Siebert

Founder & President

Grant Siebert

Director of Operations

Ryan Siebert

Director of Sports Memorabilia & Authentication

Questions & Answers
Frequently Asked Questions

How Do I Know If My Collection Is Worth Anything?

Many collections contain hidden value, especially:

Pre-1980 sports cards
Autographs
Graded cards
Vintage memorabilia
Rare sports collectibles

We provide honest evaluations and help determine current market value by researching recent sales and market trends.

Do You Buy Collections Outright or Consign Them?

We do both.

Depending on the collection, we may purchase it directly or recommend consignment if it will maximize your return.

Do You Work With Large Collections or Estates?

Yes.

We specialize in helping collectors, families, and estate representatives organize and sell large sports collections professionally and efficiently.

How Much Do You Charge?

Consignment rates vary based on:

Collection size
Collection value
Type of items

Our goal is always to maximize your return while handling the entire selling process for you.

What Makes Premier Sports Consignment Different?

We combine:

Sports expertise
Love of the hobby
Market knowledge
Personalized service

Our focus is helping collectors receive top dollar while providing a smooth, stress-free experience.

Can You Help Me Identify Valuable Cards?

Yes.

We help identify:

Key rookie cards
Hall of Fame cards
Graded cards
Autographs
Rare memorabilia

We can also help determine which items may be worth grading or authenticating.

Do I Need An Appointment?

Yes, appointments are preferred so we can give your collection the time and attention it deserves.

How Do I Get Started?

Simply:

Call us
Text us
Email us
Send photos of your collection

We’ll provide a free review and discuss your options.

Visit Premier Sports Consignment Today!

Come visit us to see what we're all about!